Transaction Costs and Tradable Permit Markets: The United States Lead Phasedown
نویسندگان
چکیده
We econometrically estimate the effect of transaction costs on the cost-effectiveness of the tradable permit market created during the US lead phasedown. We develop a methodology to identify transaction costs in the absence of price data. We find that refineries generally trade efficiently. We also, however, find evidence that transaction costs affect trading. We find evidence that refineries are less likely to trade in cases where theory suggests they will face high transaction costs. The data were collected from 30 major oil companies and include the trading partners and quantities traded for all permit trades carried out by each of 87 refineries over 8 quarters.
منابع مشابه
Policy-Induced Technology Adoption: Evidence from the U.S. Lead Phasedown
The theory of environmental regulation suggests that economic instruments, such as taxes and tradable permits, create more effective technology adoption incentives than conventional regulatory standards. We explore this issue for an important industry undergoing technological responses to a dramatic decrease in allowed pollution levels—the petroleum industry’s phasedown of lead in gasoline. Usi...
متن کاملTransactions Costs in Tradable Permit Markets: An Experimental Study of Pollution Market Designs
Many countries have adopted or are considering incentive approaches to environmental regulation, such as tradable permit schemes to control pollution. Regulators influence the success of tradable permit programs by their choice of market rules and permit allocation mechanisms. This paper uses laboratory experiments to study how the transaction costs incurred by participants interact with the in...
متن کاملMarket Power in Tradable Emission Markets: A Laboratory Testbed for Emission Trading in Port Phillip Bay, Victoria
In theory, competitive emission permit markets minimise total abatement cost for any emission ceiling. Permit markets are often imperfectly competitive, however, if they are thin and dominated by large firms. The dominant firm(s) could exercise market power and increase other firms’ costs of pollution control, while reducing their own emission control costs. This paper reports a testbed laborat...
متن کاملA Secure Electronic Market for Anonymous Transferable Emission Permits
Electronic Markets as new mechanisms for co-ordinating allocation of goods, are supposed to reduce the trading immanent transaction costs, especially when the traded goods are digitally represented. A market with no transaction costs is theoretically the most efficient possible allocation mechanism. The US government has recently passed the Acid Rain Act, which uses a system of tradable permits...
متن کاملTransaction Costs and the Performance
Tradeable-permit systems are at the center of current interest and activity in market-based reforms of environmental policy, because these systems can offer significant advantages over conventional approaches to pollution control. Unfortunately, claims made for their relative costeffectiveness have often been exaggerated. Transaction costs, which are ubiquitous in these markets, reduce trading ...
متن کامل